Comments on: Do e-ink readers need to be more like paper? https://teleread.org/2019/02/14/do-e-ink-readers-need-to-be-more-like-paper/ Blog on ebooks, publishing, libraries, tech, and related topics Thu, 09 Jan 2020 23:16:34 +0000 hourly 1 http://wordpress.com/ By: Shirley Dulcey https://teleread.org/2019/02/14/do-e-ink-readers-need-to-be-more-like-paper/#comment-123333 Thu, 09 Jan 2020 23:16:34 +0000 http://teleread.org/?p=167440#comment-123333 In reply to Michael W. Perry, medical writer.

Background music would actually be a nice enhancement to some books. But music licensing issues would likely make it impossible to do unless the e-book company also runs a music streaming service. There IS one such company…

What COULD be done would be implementation of an interface that would let the e-reader software talk to your choice of streaming music service so it could play the music from there.

Like

]]>
By: Robert Nagle https://teleread.org/2019/02/14/do-e-ink-readers-need-to-be-more-like-paper/#comment-102057 Mon, 18 Feb 2019 16:57:16 +0000 http://teleread.org/?p=167440#comment-102057 I just want to say: I switched to a 13 inch Samsung tablet a few years ago and never looked back. I want to display epubs, pdfs and mobi on the same device, and the android tablet does that perfectly. Aside from color screens, I have 64 gigs of memory and 64 gigs of external memory on the card.

That said, I am constantly using that sucker and constantly recharging it. I estimate that I’m using that thing easily 8 hours a day.

I wouldn’t mind returning to e-ink and relegating the android tablet to handle non-book stuff. But I would be looking for something 1)with hard buttons, 2)something that supports epub natively via cloud and 3)something that is a bigger form factor than the typical kindle. The Kindle Oasis is barely bigger than the Paperwhite, and yet cost twice as much? Doesn’t compute .

Like

]]>
By: Kris Schnee https://teleread.org/2019/02/14/do-e-ink-readers-need-to-be-more-like-paper/#comment-101426 Fri, 15 Feb 2019 20:54:17 +0000 http://teleread.org/?p=167440#comment-101426 I happen to like the e-ink format and the long battery life. Unfortunately, Amazon has stopped making e-ink based readers that also have text-to-speech, which I’d been using to listen to books while driving. When my current old Kindle Touch breaks, I will have no options available to get those two features together (e-ink and TTS), so I will likely switch to a tablet or laptop and never buy another dedicated reader. So, it’s a problem of the modern models being too specialized for too little benefit.

Also, battery life probably doesn’t concern most users, since mobile batteries are good enough now that recharging isn’t a big hassle. So if the only thing you’re offering is a $100+ device that does nothing but display books, the only selling point seems to be “the screen looks slightly nicer than a regular display”.

Like

]]>
By: Reader https://teleread.org/2019/02/14/do-e-ink-readers-need-to-be-more-like-paper/#comment-101403 Fri, 15 Feb 2019 18:37:41 +0000 http://teleread.org/?p=167440#comment-101403 e-ink reader sales have been declining dramatically in the last few years.

They are no longer novelties. Those who want e-readers have already purchased them: saturated market. As such, declining sales are no surprise.

I am embarrassed to tell how many e-readers I have, but suffice it to say that I have more than one.

There is no need to purchase a new e-reader every year and throw out the old model, as a lot of people used to do with cars. The Nook Simple Touch I purchased 6 years ago is still functioning, though the rubberized surface has taken a beating. That rubberized surface was not one of B&N’s better decisions.

E-reader software could use some improvements. Amazon has been fairly responsive to customer demands, like having AZW3 with traditional page numbers and fonts with adjustable boldface. B&N’s record on improving software in response to customer demands is not as good, such as bold font choices. B&N’s software on collections has improved, though.

Like

]]>
By: Michael W. Perry, medical writer https://teleread.org/2019/02/14/do-e-ink-readers-need-to-be-more-like-paper/#comment-101361 Fri, 15 Feb 2019 13:50:58 +0000 http://teleread.org/?p=167440#comment-101361 Epaper readers are dying not because they’re not enough like paper but because they do too little. They do little more than display books. Most people, concerned with their budgets and keeping down clutter, have decided to use much more versatile tablets or to make do reading on their smartphones.

I’d love to see the epaper technology adapted for other purposes. I’d like to see a book-sized epaper display that would get images from an smaller-screen iPhone yards away. I’d love to have a large-screen epaper display that could show the final appearance of books I’ve laying out with InDesign. But neither product exists probably because there’s insufficient interest on the part of the public. Their tablets and smartphones are good enough. A good enough technology people have will always win out of limited one that costs more money for only a slight improvement.
—-
The real problem with ebooks is the dreadfully inadequate epub format. There’s a wealth of things that digital books could do but don’t because epub is so ill-conceived. Those responsible for it seem to fall into two categories.

1. The geeky, nerdy type for whom hidden, esoteric stuff matters most. They’re the ones who think it a big deal that a recent update to epub downgrades on form of the ebook equivalent of a table of contents. “Who cares?,” I thought when I heard that. That contents data could be included for the next fifty years with no harm done.

2. The visionaries who lack sense. These are the ones who think that digital reading should be accompanied by multimedia, including video scenes and background music. That’s absurd. Videos are expensive to do well. Few writers and publishers can afford to add even a couple of minutes of poorly done video to their books and those who want background music while they read can turn on a radio or join a music service.

I can give an example of what epub should do. You see accordion text on webpages. it allows text to be concealed or revealed as the user choses. It’s far better than the pitful epub workaround, clumsy pop-up windows. It could be used in hundreds of ways to offer additional information in both fiction and non-fiction books, including dealing with graphics. Why isn’t it there? Why do most ebooks still look like the ones who first appeared on Palm devices twenty years ago?

That’s stupid, really stupid, and it’s why ereaders are dying and ebooks languishing. It’s even why Amazon displayed good sense when it didn’t adopt epub but chose to create its own standard.

Like

]]>